Usually, no. If your old silver (amalgam) fillings are intact and the teeth around them are healthy, Health Canada and major dental associations don’t recommend replacing them just because they contain mercury, since drilling them out releases more mercury vapour and removes healthy tooth structure. Replacement makes sense when a filling is cracked, leaking, has decay underneath, or the tooth is fractured. Old fillings wearing out is common and often slow, but a cracked tooth or decay under a filling can become serious if ignored.
Silver fillings were the go-to for decades, so many adults have a mouthful of them. Lately you may have heard about the European Union banning amalgam, or seen ads for “mercury-free” dentistry, and wondered if yours should come out. At our dental clinic in Woodbridge, this question comes up every week, and the answer depends on the condition of each filling, not its colour.
When a filling does need attention, there are good tooth-coloured options. Small and medium repairs are usually handled with composite resin under fillings and restorations, bonded to the tooth to restore its natural look.
Large old amalgams often leave teeth weakened or cracked. In those cases, single visit crowns and veneers (CEREC) can replace the filling with a ceramic restoration that protects the whole tooth, designed and placed in the same appointment.
And if you’d like your smile to look more natural overall, swapping dark fillings can be part of a wider smile design and aesthetic dentistry plan. You can see every option on the our services page before your visit.
What is an amalgam filling?
Dental amalgam is a mix of metals, roughly half liquid mercury combined with a powdered alloy of silver, tin, and copper. Once mixed, the mercury is bound into a stable material. It’s been used for more than 150 years because it’s strong, long-lasting, and handles moisture well.
In Canada, its use has dropped a lot. Most new fillings today are tooth-coloured composite resin, and amalgam is used much less often than it used to be.
Are silver fillings safe?
Amalgam fillings release very small amounts of mercury vapour, especially when you chew or grind. Health Canada’s position, first published in 1996 and reaffirmed in 2020, is that amalgam isn’t causing illness in the general population, while recommending some precautions:
- Healthy amalgam fillings in people without symptoms shouldn’t be replaced just because they contain mercury.
- Non-mercury materials are worth considering for children’s baby teeth when they’re suitable.
- Where possible, amalgam shouldn’t be placed or removed during pregnancy.
- People with kidney disease or a known mercury allergy should avoid new amalgam fillings.
Internationally, the direction is toward phasing amalgam out, largely for environmental reasons. The European Union banned most new amalgam use starting January 1, 2025, and countries under the Minamata Convention on Mercury have agreed to phase it down. Canada hasn’t banned it, but use is low and falling.
Why removing healthy amalgam can do more harm than good
- Drilling out amalgam releases a short burst of mercury vapour, more than the filling releases sitting in your tooth.
- Every replacement removes some healthy tooth structure, making the tooth weaker.
- Each new filling restarts the clock on the tooth’s “restoration cycle,” bringing it closer to needing a crown or root canal someday.
When should old silver fillings be replaced?
Replace a filling because of its condition. Good reasons include:
- Recurrent decay: new cavities forming under or around the edges
- Cracks: in the filling or in the tooth itself, often seen as fine lines spreading from the filling
- Leaking margins: gaps where the filling meets the tooth, often shown by dark staining
- Broken pieces: part of the filling or tooth has chipped off
- Pain: sensitivity or pain when biting that points to a crack
- Allergy: a rare, confirmed allergy to mercury or other metals
- Cosmetic concerns: visible fillings you’d like to change, after discussing the trade-offs
Signs your old filling may be failing
- Sharp pain when biting or releasing a bite
- New sensitivity to cold or sweets
- Food catching in the same spot
- Floss shredding near a filling
- A dark or grey shadow spreading around the filling
- A rough edge you can feel with your tongue
Replacement options compared
| Option | Best for | Pros | Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Composite (tooth-coloured) filling | Small to medium cavities | Natural look, bonds to tooth, conservative | Can wear faster under heavy biting; technique-sensitive |
| Ceramic inlay or onlay | Larger fillings with strong outer walls | Very durable, natural look, saves more tooth than a crown | Needs precise fit; usually more involved than a filling |
| CEREC same-day crown | Cracked or heavily filled teeth | Full protection, done in one visit, no temporary | Removes more tooth structure than a filling |
| Leaving it alone | Intact fillings with healthy teeth | No tooth loss, no vapour exposure from drilling | Needs monitoring at checkups |
What happens when a filling is replaced, step by step
- Exam and X-rays to confirm the filling needs replacing and check for decay.
- Freezing to keep you comfortable.
- Isolation: a rubber dam and high-volume suction to keep the area clean and reduce exposure to particles and vapour.
- Removal: the old amalgam is sectioned and removed in chunks, with lots of water spray.
- Decay removal and checking for cracks.
- Restoration: composite filling, onlay, or crown, depending on how much healthy tooth remains.
- Bite check and polish.
Same-day option: when a tooth needs a crown after removing a large amalgam, CEREC lets the dentist scan, design, and mill a ceramic crown in the office, so you leave with your final restoration the same day.
Common myths about silver fillings
“All amalgam fillings should be removed for health reasons.”
Health authorities in Canada and the US don’t recommend removing intact fillings for general health reasons. Replacement should be based on the condition of the filling and tooth.
“Tooth-coloured fillings last forever.”
No filling lasts forever. Composite fillings often last many years, and their lifespan depends on size, location, bite, and home care.
“Removing amalgam will cure fatigue or other symptoms.”
Good-quality research hasn’t shown that removing amalgam fillings improves general symptoms in most people. If you have health concerns, talk with your doctor as well as your dentist.
“If a filling looks dark, it’s failing.”
Amalgam naturally darkens over time. Darkness alone isn’t a problem; leaking edges, cracks, and decay are.
Amalgam vs. composite: how do they compare?
| Amalgam (silver) | Composite (tooth-coloured) | |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Silver, darkens over time | Matches natural tooth colour |
| How it stays in | Mechanical retention; often needs more drilling | Bonded to tooth; more conservative |
| Durability | Very durable in large back-tooth fillings | Durable; may wear faster in very large fillings or heavy grinders |
| Moisture tolerance during placement | Good | Needs a dry field |
| Sensitivity after placement | Possible with temperature changes | Occasional short-term sensitivity |
| Environmental impact | Contains mercury; needs special waste handling | Mercury-free |
What dentists look for when checking old fillings
At a checkup, your dentist examines each filling closely, often with magnification and X-rays. Key things they check:
- Margins: is the edge tight against the tooth, or is there a gap or ledge?
- Fracture lines: cracks in the tooth radiating from the filling, which can spread over time
- Decay on X-rays: dark areas under or beside the filling
- Wear: flattening or ditching that changes how teeth meet
- Symptoms: pain on biting, cold sensitivity, or food trapping
Intraoral photos are especially helpful here. Seeing a crack or leaking edge on a screen makes it much easier to decide what to do, and it helps you compare changes at future visits.
Who should take extra care?
- Pregnant or breastfeeding patients: elective removal or placement of amalgam is usually postponed. Urgent dental needs should still be treated.
- Children: tooth-coloured materials are typically preferred for baby teeth.
- People with kidney disease: new amalgam fillings are generally avoided.
- People with metal allergies: rare, but confirmed allergies should guide material choice.
Safety note: if a filling breaks and you have sharp pain, swelling, or pain when biting, see a dentist promptly. A cracked tooth can split further, and decay under an old filling can reach the nerve.
Real patient scenarios
The 30-year-old fillings: a 58-year-old wanted all 6 of his old silver fillings replaced after reading online. The exam showed 4 intact fillings and 2 with cracks and decay. He replaced the 2 failing ones and kept monitoring the rest, saving healthy tooth structure.
The cracked molar: a 44-year-old felt a sharp pain when chewing on a tooth with a large amalgam. A crack ran under the filling. The filling was removed and a CEREC crown placed in the same visit, and the pain stopped.
The cosmetic upgrade: a 35-year-old disliked the dark fillings that showed when she laughed. After discussing the trade-offs, she replaced 2 visible fillings with composite as part of a smile design plan.
How to make your fillings last longer
- Brush twice daily with fluoride toothpaste
- Clean between your teeth every day
- Limit sugary snacks and acidic drinks
- Wear a night guard if you grind
- Don’t chew ice or hard objects
- Keep regular checkups so failing edges are caught early
Choosing a dentist in Woodbridge for filling replacement
A good dentist will show you X-rays and photos of each filling, explain which ones need work and why, and never push unnecessary replacements. Make sure care comes from licensed dental professionals registered with the Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario (RCDSO).
Columbus Dental Centre has served Woodbridge and the Vaughan community for over 26 years and is trusted for family and cosmetic dental care. New patients and CDCP (Canadian Dental Care Plan) patients are welcome.
The clinic uses CEREC single-visit crowns and veneers technology for same-appointment ceramic restorations. Services include smile design, dentures, bridges, CEREC crowns, oral surgery, fillings, root canal, dental implants, teeth whitening, preventive care, children dentistry, and laser dentistry. Extended hours include Monday 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM and Saturday 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM.
Visit Suite #201, 8333 Weston Rd, Woodbridge, Ontario, call +1 647-931-1100, or email columbusdentalcentre@gmail.com. The team responds quickly to questions about broken or painful fillings.
This article is general information. Decisions about replacing fillings should be made with your dentist after an exam, and with your doctor if you have specific health concerns.
FAQs
Is it safe to keep my old silver fillings?
For most people, yes, if the fillings are intact and the teeth are healthy. Health Canada doesn’t recommend removing sound amalgam fillings just because they contain mercury.
How long do amalgam fillings last?
Many last 10 to 15 years or longer. Lifespan depends on size, location, bite forces, grinding, and home care.
Can I replace silver fillings with white ones?
Yes. Composite fillings, ceramic inlays or onlays, or crowns can replace amalgam. The best choice depends on how much healthy tooth remains.
Is amalgam banned in Canada?
No. Canada hasn’t banned dental amalgam, though its use has declined sharply. The European Union banned most new amalgam use starting in 2025.
Should I replace my fillings during pregnancy?
Elective replacement is usually postponed during pregnancy. If a filling is broken or causing pain, talk with your dentist about safe options.
Conclusion
Intact silver fillings in healthy teeth usually don’t need to be replaced.
Replace fillings that are cracked, leaking, or have decay underneath, using tooth-coloured fillings, onlays, or crowns.
An exam with X-rays tells you which fillings need attention and which can stay.





